Yassmin Abdel-Magied, ANZAC Day, The ABC: Get Some Perspective

IN THE brouhaha over a token ABC “celebrity” indulging her proven immaturity and lack of any sense of occasion by posting disrespectful left-wing propaganda on Facebook, one point is clear; this is no question of free speech, much less one of Ms Abdel-Magied’s religious views — this time — but of the ABC’s role as a taxpayer-funded national broadcaster, and what it tolerates in terms of content, balance, and the behaviour of some of its staff.

Some years ago, as the Abbott government contemplated, then shied away from, sorely needed reform of section 18c of the Racial Discrimination Act, Attorney-General George Brandis waded into the debate with the inadvisable and cringeworthy observation that “people are entitled to be bigots;” widely slated for this crass (and politically damaging) utterance, Brandis was pilloried across the country, branded — among other things — as “a bigot” himself; I’ve known George for decades, and whilst I haven’t seen him for a while, he never changes. The last thing anyone who knows him would call him is “a bigot.”

Yet Brandis, in the literal sense, was correct; it is not the role of government to legislate thought, and nor should it be the role of government to legislate speech; people must have the right to think and say whatever they like: but the reciprocal obligation is upon the rest of us, whenever and wherever the nutcases show themselves, to shout them down and show their words for the offence to reality they are.

And small point as it might be to note, Brandis wasn’t actually encouraging people to be bigots. Quite the contrary.

At the time, the voices who shout loudest in this country (which emanate almost exclusively from the Left, amplified by such fine institutions as the Fairfax press and the ABC) pronounced with all the finger-shaking pomposity they could muster that not only was Brandis Public Enemy #1, but that his “honesty” amounted to an unrebuttable case as to why S18c should be strengthened, not watered down or (God forbid!) abolished altogether (as it should be).

Fast forward to early this year, and that waste of taxpayer cash, Gillian Triggs, found her way into the public discourse with a diatribe lamenting that it was regrettable that the state was unable to control the “free speech” that occurred around the kitchen tables of family homes around Australia: and if this didn’t frighten the hell out of ordinary good folk, whose only real crime is to have an opinion, then I don’t know what would.

I begin my remarks this morning thus because as a fervent champion of free speech — genuinely free speech — I have watched over the past few years, with increasing dismay, as this issue (which ought to be something Australia as a country is renowned the world over for as a strong, free country) has become little more than a political football and a slogan to be kicked around and used to hurt opponents politically.

And with ANZAC Day having been and gone again for another year, this year’s festivities have been marred by an ugly public spat over a despicable post in social media by someone who should have known better, employed by people who ought to have provided the guidance to stop her.

By now, most people will have heard of the fracas over Muslim ABC identity Yassmin Abdel-Magied’s foolhardy words on Facebook; those who haven’t can check out this article from The Australian (and I am using this, rather than any of the other reports available, as I wanted to include the opinion offered by Graham Richardson on the issue).

“Lest we forget (Nauru, Manus, Syria, Palestine),” she wrote. This reference to the hard-Left agenda of ending offshore detention, withdrawing from the Middle East and its obsession with sticking fingers (or worse) into the eyes of Israel is too blatant to claim as a coincidence, and too tastelessly timed to be anything other than a jab at another object of left-wing hatred: ANZAC Day.

Predictably, the voices of the Right roared. It was obscene, un-Australian, treacherous, disrespectful, blasphemous, an insult to the men and women who fought and died for Australia’s freedom.

It was indeed all of those things.

But the voices of the Left returned fire, claiming that calls for Ms Abdel-Magied to be sacked by the ABC proved that once and for all, the great conservative cause of free speech was nothing but a hoax; here they were, trying to shut down “free speech” from someone on the Left. How dare they! After all, Abdel-Magied was entitled to offer an opinion, wasn’t she? Or was this just because Abdel-Magied is a Muslim, and conservatives are “bigots?”

Yet again, the football that is free speech gets kicked around — and the central point (or in this case, problem) is missed.

This column believes Ms Abdel-Magied should be free to think whatever she likes, turgid and contemptible as some of those sentiments are: and courtesy of her status as one of the ABC’s tokenistic fabricated “celebrities” — who, to be blunt, would be of little interest to anyone, the ABC included, were it not for the fact she hails from a minority community — we are learning more and more about the thoughts of this lamentable excuse for a TV personality.

Such as the ridiculous notion that Islam is “the most feminist religion” in the world, when irrefutable evidence of the savagery and barbarism of fundamentalist Islamic regimes towards women in many parts of the world tells a very different story.

Or the equally fatuous suggestion that Sharia Law is purely concerned with “mercy and kindness,” and that the law of sovereign nations always takes precedence over it — when again, there is ample evidence over many years and from many countries that nothing could be further from the truth.

I think Ms Abdel-Magied is shrewd; she’s been appointed to government taskforces on multiculturalism and domestic violence; she was sent on a tour of Muslim countries by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade to “promote Australia;” she was appointed to the board of the Queensland Museum; and she’s been packaged up as a “media identity” by the ABC (possibly as the ABC’s answer to Waleed Aly on The Project, about whom my objection has nothing to do with the fact he’s a Muslim and everything to do with the fact he’s a socialist idiot whose views I vehemently disagree with).

Even in an era where political, social and cultural institutions are dominated by the Left in this country, it still takes a degree of guile to extract and compile that kind of CV — much of it with salary cheques attached to it — especially for a 26-year-old, no less, and it is obvious that guile is not a commodity in which Abdel-Magied is lacking.

But I don’t think her views are in any way representative of the silent majority of Australians; and I think elements of those views are so insidious that it behoves anyone dishing out what can only be described as CV-building items to think long and hard about what kind of national “celebrities” they are creating.

Herein lies the nub of the matter: the culpability of the ABC.

“Their ABC.” The ABC of the finger-shaking Chardonnay drunks of the self-styled “elites” of the Left who would have a clear world view if they could only extract their heads from their rectums.

Too much of what the ABC puts to air — especially where politics and current affairs are concerned, and especially wherever any kind of panel or discussion is involved — is unapologetically misused as a forum to advance the causes of the political Left; whether it’s to omit key details from its coverage (like failing to identify Islamic terrorist acts as being committed by Muslims) or to stack the loathsome #QandA panel every week with a majority of leftist and radical socialist identities, the only time the ABC feigns any pretence of impartiality is when anyone tries to hold it to account.

My point is that for all the (justified) uproar over what Ms Abdel-Magied had to say on Facebook, the ruckus isn’t a question of free speech: Abdel-Magied was free to post what she did, and the rest of us were free to slap it down as the odious rubbish it was. The fact she took the post down (and apologised) is a clue that someone belatedly got through to her that there are some things you just don’t do.

But organisations like the ABC, which are responsible for providing people like Abdel-Magied a national platform from which to disseminate fringe opinions, also bear some responsibility for what their media creations subsequently say or do: if Yassmin Abdel-Magied was just a nameless resident of Brisbane — irrespective of her religious convictions — who posted something like she did on ANZAC Day, it’s doubtful anyone would have noticed, let alone cause the fuss we’ve seen over the past two days.

No big media profile, no public interest in social media profiles. One follows the other. The ABC made her a “star.” Its curt dismissal of her post, or the callous claim that deleting it was “acceptable,” simply isn’t good enough.

If you create the monster, you own its handiwork. The ABC can’t have it both ways.

Nobody doubts Ms Abdel-Magied’s ability; and nobody could criticise the daughter of migrants trying to carve out a niche for herself. It is her judgement that is in question.

Whilst she should be free to think (and indeed, say) whatever she likes, trying to misappropriate the national spotlight for herself on what is tantamount to a sacred day in Australia, with opinions that are offensive drivel to most Australians, is not the way to go about it.

Through her public utterances on #QandA and this week through her deleted Facebook post, whatever else you might think of her, Ms Abdel-Magied has exhibited a distinct lack of maturity: and if she can’t or won’t behave like a grown-up, then those who dish out the dough — like her employers at “Their ABC” — ought to think twice about providing her with taxpayer-funded junkets and/or platforms to spruik her wares.

Where the ABC is concerned, the notion of being “independent” is too easily distorted into an excuse to propagate blatantly biased left-wing propaganda, using carefully selected messengers (such as Ms Abdel-Magied) to enable dissent to be portrayed as a racist/sexist/homophobic/Islamophobic (insert your favourite lefty taunt here) attack on nice people with “valid insights.”

Sorry Aunty. You created her and if you can’t control her, piss her off. The rest of us don’t need to be lectured, and especially not by a kid who apparently doesn’t even value the traditions of the country that has given her a better life than her homeland ever would have.

 

 

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Yassmin Abdel-Magied, ANZAC Day, The ABC: Get Some Perspective

  1. Another good column. This is not a free speech issue. It is about the balance (or lack of balance) constantly on display at (Their) ABC. The ABC is now a monster that the LIB/Nats cannot dare try and control because it will turn on them and savage them. But the reality is that it constantly savages them anyway. The best option is to strike hard and fast. Break it up into a number of smaller businesses. Sell these (including SBS) to the highest bidder and stop using taxpayers funds to fund business that is in competition to private sector businesses. Make it a subscription service if necessary, but transform it into something that is not out of control. Transform it into something that doesn’t demand that I pay and forces me to pay for content and material that doesn’t reflect my views.
    But the Lib/Nat government is too weak and afraid, and is he leadership of a person who is at best ambivalent about the out of control nature of the ABC.

    • Exactly. In 2017, with the country on its way to a trillion indebtedness, there is absolutely no justification for a public “broadcaster”. There is simply no legitimate role for government in this or any industry.

      • “No justification for a public broadcaster, and no legitimate role for government in this or any industry” – what crap, did the dog you use as your likeness tell you to write that?
        With only private broadcasters, there would be no voice for anyone with a viewpoint that did not agree with the proprietors of the media or their advertising clients, independent journalism would be unheard of and commercialism would rule – there would be no distinction between advertising and editorial, cash for comment (remember the John Laws and Alan Jones cases) would be the norm

        Keep up with your ABC bashing, it gives me a laugh to think you actually believe it.

  2. Perhaps a class 18C action against her for offense taken against our race and culture might close that big and odious mouth.

  3. A couple of other enlightening posts from Magied: “Brisbane is as white as fuck” and “26th January was a day of slaughter”. Her associates at Hizb ut-Tahir would approve and so would the ABC.

    • It all merely underscores the point, doesn’t it?

      Incidentally, having spent 25 days a year in Brisbane over the past couple of years after leaving 20 years ago, “white as fuck” is certainly not a metaphor I would use to describe it.

      Maybe 20+ years ago (although even then it would be a stretch) but certainly not now.

      Either Ms Abdel-Magied lives in a different town to the one I have watched change over many years, or she lives on a different planet altogether.

  4. Guys, this is a storm in a “TEA CUP”. This person has an Agenda and with all the fuss that has been made, she has achieved that Agenda and can now take the message down & apologies etc., confident that she has been successful. In actual fact who cares? Personally if she fell off the planet tomorrow I would definitely not be heart broken!

    Lets us not forget what ANZAC day means :- Let us never forget those who lost their lives in defence of our country, in all conflicts, not just at Gallipoli.

  5. I’m fairly confident that this twit (or whatever it was) written by this twit (or whatever she is) was merely two things:
    One, a personal dissatisfaction with the way many Australians don’t agree with her, or even like her;
    And two, more importantly to her, a deliberate attempt to self advertise. A venture which has been extremely successful! Even Yale has given her some oxygen, as, I suppose, have I.
    She has generated months of lucrative interviews, talks and speeches. She has ensured her tenure at the ABC continues for years, as a result of the ABC’s determination to maintain an attitude that is totally Leftward. The ABC will, because of the backlash generated, immediately raise a finger to any and all who dare – say by petition – to try and enforce the ABC to do anything! They are a law unto themselves, and intend to maintain that position, which is amply supported by all Governments.
    Exhibit Barnaby Joyce, “Aww gee fellers, tone it down a bit willya! Doncha know how hard it is fer me to keep funding you with Millions of Dollars that could be much better spent elsewhere! FFS, you now how to lie and cheat! Keep lying to and cheating the public and us morons in Parliament, and don’t make it too hard for us to suck up to you.”
    The solution to any conservative who had been discredited, lied to by, or cheated by the ABC is simple –
    Don’t be so bloody stupid as to appear on any ABC program.

  6. Yale! Is this the quality of the intellectual minnows that read your rants? I was expecting some erudition, some cogent argument for positions assumed, some rationality from the conservative camp! And what did we get? Hansonist, racist garbage spewed from the mouths of the incognoscenti, afraid that the bogeyman will come and get them! Erudite debate? Not here I’m afraid! 😩😧

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s